County school districts rate high on finacial accountability

Center, TImpson, Excelsior & Shelbyville earn highest marks

Shelby County independent school districts fared well in the latest round of state financial accountability rating released by the Texas Education Agency.

Center ISD, Timpson ISD, Excelsior ISD and Shelbyville ISD each received a superior rating while both Joaquin ISD and Tenaha ISD received above standard ratings by TEA. Center, Timpson and Shelbyville districts each earned an “A” rating while Tenaha and Joaquin received a “B” letter grade, the agency reported.

The TEA on Wednesday released preliminary financial accountability ratings for more than 1,100 school districts and charters across the state, with 80 percent earning the highest preliminary rating possible for 2017-2018.

Created by the 77th Texas Legislature in 2001, the School Financial Integrity Rating System of Texas (FIRST) is designed to encourage public schools to better manage their financial resources to provide the maximum allocation possible for direct instructional purposes.


The FIRST ratings are calculated using 15 financial indicators, such as administrative cost expenditures; the accuracy of a district or charter’s financial information submitted to TEA; and any financial vulnerabilities or material weaknesses in internal controls as determined by an external auditor.


Ratings for 2017-2018 are based on annual financial reports provided to TEA by districts and charters for the 2017 fiscal year. The financial accountability system requires TEA to review the audited financial reports from all districts and charters.


A school district or open-enrollment charter is assigned one of four possible letter grades (A, B, C or F), as well as a coinciding financial management rating (Superior, Above Standard Achievement, Meets Standard or Substandard Achievement).


For 2017-2018, the preliminary FIRST ratings are as follows:


Preliminary Rating





A – Superior





B – Above Standard Achievement





C – Meets Standard





F – Substandard Achievement











There are five critical indicators that result in an automatic F or Substandard Achievement rating should a school district or open-enrollment charter fail in that specific category – regardless of overall score.


In addition, preliminary FIRST ratings for charter schools operated by a public institution of higher education (IHE) are being assigned for the first time. Based on 7 indicators, IHEs are assigned either a Pass or Fail rating. For 2017-2018, every public institution of higher education operating a charter school (7) received a preliminary FIRST rating of Pass.


For IHEs, there are two critical indicators that result in an automatic Fail rating should an IHE fail in that specific category – regardless of the overall score.


All school districts and charters are required to report information and financial accountability ratings to parents and taxpayers. In addition, districts and charters must hold a public discussion or hearing regarding its financial report.


TEA has formally notified school districts and charters of their preliminary FIRST rating. Any district or charter wishing to appeal its rating must submit a written appeal, with supporting evidence, to TEA by Sept. 10, 2018. Following a review of all the submitted appeals, final 2017­-2018 school FIRST ratings are expected to be released in October.


If no appeal is submitted to TEA by the district or charter school, the preliminary rating becomes final on the 31st day after preliminary ratings are released.


To review the preliminary 2017-2018 FIRST ratings for all districts and charters (plus view final FIRST ratings from previous years), visit the TEA website at